Free U.S. Shipping on Orders Over $49. Use Code: FASHIP49. Each offer has a limited duration that expires at the specified time. Some promotions may require that you enter a code. By making a purchase featuring a discount or promotion, including where a code may be required, you are agreeing to these terms and exclusions. Generally, eligibility will be as reflected in the price shown on the product page. However, discounts and promotions for certain products may only appear once an item is added to the cart and the code is entered. Prices and fees, including any applicable discount(s), will be as reflected in the cart. Only the as-discounted retail price (excluding applicable shipping, taxes, and handling fees) counts toward any minimum spend required for eligibility. If a rewards program applies, the rewards may only apply to the as-discounted retail price. Discounts and promotions do not apply to gift cards. Gift card purchases do not count toward any minimum spend required for eligibility. Exclusions may apply, including: all auctions and product drops; product that is already on sale, of limited quantity, for recent championship or other special events; trading cards and certain memorabilia; select jerseys, on-field headwear, die cast and certain collectibles; and certain premium brand product. Additional terms and other exclusions may apply in our sole discretion. Items listed as FINAL SALE on the product page are final sale and cannot be returned. Free shipping promotions are valid in Continental U.S., US Territories, and AFO/FPO only, such promotions exclude heavy, large, and/or bulky items, and free shipping does not apply to the extent your cart at checkout contains any excluded item(s). Shipping method and timing may vary. Expected delivery times are based on in-stock items and the specified zip code, if applicable. Delivery estimates are not guaranteed.
  1. MLB
  2. Trading Cards
  3. Singles Trading Cards
  4. Fanatics Authentic Stocking Stuffers
  5. Unsigned
1 - 72 of 127
Fanatics Authentic Stocking Stuffers
Atlanta BravesBaltimore OriolesBoston Red SoxChicago CubsDetroit TigersHouston AstrosLos Angeles AngelsLos Angeles DodgersMilwaukee BrewersNew York MetsNew York YankeesPhiladelphia PhilliesSeattle MarinersSt. Louis CardinalsTampa Bay Rays
127 Items
Atlanta BravesBaltimore OriolesBoston Red SoxChicago CubsDetroit TigersHouston AstrosLos Angeles AngelsLos Angeles DodgersMilwaukee BrewersNew York MetsNew York YankeesPhiladelphia PhilliesSeattle MarinersSt. Louis CardinalsTampa Bay Rays
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Angels 2023 Topps Now 8th MLB Player Ever w/ 2+ 40Hrs & 20SBs Season #811 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2023 Topps Now 2023 MLB All-Star Game Selection - AL #ASG-JR BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Randy Arozarena Tampa Bay Rays 2023 Topps Now Black 2023 MLB All-Star Game Selection - AL #ASG-RA #/99 CGC Authenticated 10 Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Juan Soto New York Mets 2025 Topps Now 1st Home Run with Mets Is A Majestic Moonshot #17 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Gerrit Cole New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 1st Player with 200K in 3 Seasons for the Yankees #844 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Brett Baty New York Mets 2022 Topps Now Slugs Two-Run Homer In 1st Career At-Bat #729 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Michael Harris Atlanta Braves 2022 Topps Now 2022 NL Rookie of The Year Award Winner 11.14.2022 #OS-35 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Ronny Mauricio New York Mets 2023 Topps Now Cracks 1st Homer Of MLB Career #858 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,9.5,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Jordan Walker St. Louis Cardinals 2023 Topps Now 20-Year-Old Get First Hit On Opening Day #7 CGC Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Pete Alonso New York Mets 2022 Topps Now Mets RBI Single Season Record #960 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Jasson Dominguez New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Youngest Since 1901 To Belt 4HRs In 1st 7 Games #834 CGC Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Roki Sasaki Los Angeles Dodgers 2025 Topps Now Anticipated MLB Debut Comes In Home Country #3 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$59.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Yankees Top Prospect Make His Big-League Debut #2 CGC Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Yoshinobu Yamamoto & Shota Imanaga 2025 Topps Now 1st Japanese Starting Pitchers To Square Off On Opening Day #2 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 13/13 Steals To Start Career Bests DiMaggio #283 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Jordan Walker St. Louis Cardinals 2023 Topps Now Youngest Cardinals 4-Hit Game #787 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Brett Baty New York Mets 2022 Topps Now 2-Run Homer in 1st at Bat #729 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Mookie Betts Los Angeles Dodgers 2024 Topps TBT 90 Topps Ames All-Stars #96 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Grayson Rodriguez Baltimore Orioles 2023 Topps Now Orioles Top Prospect Makes His MLB Debut In Texas #57 CGC Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Pete Alonso New York Mets 2023 Topps Now 10th All-time Mets RBI List #713 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Juan Soto New York Mets 2025 Topps Now 1st Home Run with Mets Is A Majestic Moonshot #17 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2023 Topps Now Fastest in Mariners History to Reach 50 HRs #765 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Jackson Holliday Baltimore Orioles 2024 Topps Now Happy Hollidays! 1st MLB HR is Grand Slam 07.31.24 #498 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Colton Cowser Baltimore Orioles 2024 Topps Now 2024 Rookie Cup Team #RC8 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Jackson Holliday Baltimore Orioles 2024 Topps Now Happy Hollidays! 1st MLB HR is Grand Slam 07.31.24 #498 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,9.5,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2023 Topps Now 2nd Player w/ 175+ RBI & 60+ SBs Over 1st 2 Season #897 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Paul Skenes, Elly De La Cruz and Gunnar Henderson 2025 Topps Now MLB The Show 25 Cover Athletes Revealed #OS-17 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Most Popular in Collectibles & Memorabilia
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2023 Topps Now 2nd Player W/ 175+ RBI & 60+ SBs Over 1st 2 Season #897 CGC Authenticated 10 Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 1st Yankees Rookie w/ 20 HR's & 20 SB's in a Season #792 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Paul Skenes, Elly De La Cruz and Gunnar Henderson 2025 Topps Now MLB The Show 25 Cover Athletes Revealed #OS-17 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,9.5,10 Subgrades
Most Popular in Collectibles & Memorabilia
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 1st Career Homerun #899 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
J.T. Realmuto Philadelphia Phillies 2023 Topps Now Most Postseason HRs By A Catcher #982 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Spencer Torkelson Detroit Tigers 2023 Topps Now 1st Career Walk-Off Homerun #432 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2023 Topps Now 1st Mariners Player w/ 3 Consecutive 4+ Hit Games #723 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 1st Career Homerun #899 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Ronny Mauricio New York Mets 2023 Topps Now Cracks 1st Homer Of MLB Career #858 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$59.99
J.T. Realmuto Philadelphia Phillies 2023 Topps Now Most Postseason HRs By A Phillies Catcher #982 CGC Authenticated 10 Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Jackson Holliday Baltimore Orioles 2024 Topps Now Happy Hollidays! 1st MLB HR is Grand Slam 07.31.24 #498 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2023 Topps Now 1st Mariners Player w/ 3 Consecutive 4+ Hit Games #723 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Yoshinobu Yamamoto & Shota Imanaga 2025 Topps Now 1st Japanese Starting Pitchers To Square Off On Opening Day #2 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Jasson Dominguez New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 4th Yankees Player To Homer In 2 Of His 1st 3 Games #812 CGC Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2023 Topps Now Fastest in Mariners History to Reach 50 HRs #765 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Blasts 1st Career Grand Slam 05.10.23 #264 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,9.5,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Grayson Rodriguez Baltimore Orioles 2023 Topps Now Whiffs Nine Batters En-Route To 1st MLB Victory #200 CGC Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Pete Alonso New York Mets 2023 Topps Now 10th All-time Mets RBI List #713 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2023 Topps Now Sets New Single Round Record in 2023 T-Mobile Home Run Derby #558 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Leads Off & Hits 1st MLB HR in 1st Inning #119 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2023 Topps Now Fastest in Mariners History to Reach 50 HRs #765 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,9.5,10 Subgrades
Ships Free
$69.99
Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now HR in MLB Debut #798 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Carson Kelly Chicago Cubs 2025 Topps Now 1st Cubs Cycle Since 1993 Fuels Blowout Win #ODB2 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,9.5,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Colt Keith Detroit Tigers 2024 Topps Now MLB Rookie Cup Team Pearl #RC-3 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 13/13 Steals To Start Career Bests DiMaggio #283 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Austin Wells New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 1st Career Homerun #899 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 1st HR at Yankee Stadium #827 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Michael Harris II Atlanta Braves 2022 Topps Now Off-Season 2022 NL Rookie Of The Year Award Winner #OS-35 CGC Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$59.99
Brett Baty New York Mets 2022 Topps Now Slugs Two-Run Homer In 1st Career MLB At-Bat #729 CGC Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Cam Smith Houston Astros 2025 Topps Now Astros Top Prospect Collects Hit in MLB Debut #9 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$59.99
DNU Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Joins Rare Company With 1st HR At Yankee Stadium #827 CGC Authenticated 10 Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Leads Off & Hits 1st MLB HR in 1st Inning #119 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,9.5,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$59.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Collects 1st Hit & Runs Into Yankees Record Book #22 CGC Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Joey Ortiz Milwaukee Brewers 2024 Topps Now Rookie Cup Team #RC-4 CGC Authenticated 10 Card
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2023 Topps Now 4th Player w/ 30 HR & 30 SB Season By Age 22 #855 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Ronny Mauricio New York Mets 2023 Topps Now Cracks 1st Homer Of MLB Career #858 CGC Authenticated 10 Rookie Card
Ships Free
$69.99
Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now HR in MLB Debut #798 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Michael Harris Atlanta Braves 2022 Topps Now 2022 NL Rookie of The Year Award Winner 11.14.2022 #OS-35 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Youngest Since 1901 to Belt 4 HR's in 1st 7 Games #834 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Julio Rodriguez Seattle Mariners 2023 Topps Now 4th Player w/ 30 HR & 30 SB Season By Age 22 #855 BGS Authenticated 10 Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Jasson Domínguez New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now Youngest Since 1901 to Belt 4 HR's in 1st 7 Games #834 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,9.5,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Cam Smith Houston Astros 2025 Topps Now Astros Top Prospect Collects Hit in MLB Debut #9 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Anthony Volpe New York Yankees 2023 Topps Now 1st Yankees Rookie w/ 20 HR's & 20 SB's in a Season #792 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 9.5,10,10,10 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Kristian Campbell Boston Red Sox 2025 Topps Now 22 Year Old Prospect Notches 1st Hit in MLB Debut #11 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,10,10,9.5 Subgrades
Almost Gone!
Ships Free
$69.99
Jordan Walker St. Louis Cardinals 2023 Topps Now Youngest Cardinals 4-Hit Game #787 BGS Authenticated 10 Rookie Card - 10,9.5,10,10 Subgrades
Atlanta BravesBaltimore OriolesBoston Red SoxChicago CubsDetroit TigersHouston AstrosLos Angeles AngelsLos Angeles DodgersMilwaukee BrewersNew York MetsNew York YankeesPhiladelphia PhilliesSeattle MarinersSt. Louis CardinalsTampa Bay Rays